Bad day for Journalists

This came in today from the Kur­dis­tan Jour­nal­ists’ Union while I was tak­ing care of last minute logis­tics before head­ing out toward Kalek and/or Kirkuk. (Sorry for the light last few days… I’ve been get­ting my legs under me, so to speak.)

Kur­dis­tan Jour­nal­ists’ Union’s State­ment on the way Ara­bic Media chan­nels deal with Oper­a­tion Iraqi Freedom
While Iraq is wit­ness­ing a deci­sive war to lib­er­ate it from 35 long years under the Iraqi Ba’athist Regime’s repres­sive rule, the world Mass Media cor­re­spon­dents and jour­nal­ists are now con­tin­u­ously report­ing the events of Oper­a­tion Iraqi Free­dom using the lat­est tech­nol­ogy invented in the field of com­mu­ni­ca­tion. This coali­tion oper­a­tion is extremely impor­tant, not only for the lives of the Iraqi peo­ples, but also for the whole Region and the world, as it will also impacts [sic] many polit­i­cal equi­ties. [sic]
At the same time, and as events are unfold­ing, we empha­size on the impor­tance and effect of jour­nal­ism on today’s world. And while free Media activ­i­ties are restricted in the areas con­trolled by the Iraqi regime, we find that Iraqi Kur­dis­tan Region is main­tain­ing a real democ­racy for 12 years that paved the way for jour­nal­ists, rep­re­sent­ing dif­fer­ent media chan­nels in the entire world, to report as freely as they like ben­e­fit­ing from the atmos­phere of free­dom in Iraqi Kur­dis­tan.
We believe that the regional Media Chan­nels in gen­eral and Ara­bic ones in par­tic­u­lar, have the right to report on the events from their own point of view and prac­tice their rights as jour­nal­ists; since the free­doms of knowl­edge and report­ing news are a part of the gen­eral free­doms. But unfor­tu­nately, some Ara­bic Media Chan­nels, espe­cially the Satel­lite Tele­vi­sions are try­ing to play down and degrade the Iraqi people’s demands and wishes of free­dom and democ­racy. They still turn a blind eye on over 35 years of iso­la­tion, repres­sion, suf­fer­ing and the dreams of Iraqi peo­ples in their cov­er­age of news and events.
These Ara­bic Satel­lite chan­nels have used a bias lan­guage in por­tray­ing the facts they reported about the suf­fer­ing of the Iraqi peo­ple. They not only became a mouth­piece for the dem­a­gogic poli­cies of that dying fas­cist regime, but they started to use cov­ers of Islam and Ara­bism in spread­ing the regime’s pro­pa­ganda. They exceeded the rules of true jour­nal­ism, trod on all the prin­ci­ples of free­dom, democ­racy and human rights and became a tool in the hands of Sad­dam Hus­sein.
We as Kur­dis­tan jour­nal­ists con­sider the Ara­bic Mass Media as a party that stands against the process of Lib­er­at­ing Iraq from dic­ta­tor­ship; there­fore, Kur­dis­tan jour­nal­ists and all the free­dom and democ­racy seek­ers of all Iraq, includ­ing all its eth­nic groups and reli­gions, strong con­demn this neg­a­tive pro­pa­ganda that is released by the Ara­bic Satel­lite Tele­vi­sions.
[Empha­sis added — Chris]
Fur­ther­more, the Kur­dis­tan Jour­nal­ists Union strongly rejects such –address– [sic] that these Ara­bic Satel­lite Tele­vi­sions are using in describ­ing the cur­rent gen­eral and polit­i­cal sit­u­a­tion in Iraqi Kur­dis­tan Region in par­tic­u­lar, and those of Iraq in gen­eral, and we con­sider their address as a defama­tion cam­paign.
And as Iraqi Kur­dis­tan Region is always keen to main­tain the free­doms of speech and jour­nal­ism, and as there is no cen­sor­ship on all jour­nal­is­tic activ­ity in the region to a degree that even the cor­re­spon­dents of world satel­lite tele­vi­sions tes­tify to this fact, we say that these Ara­bic Sat. TVs should have con­veyed their news and reports truth­fully and in an objec­tive lan­guage so that the pub­lic opin­ion will not be mis­led. There­fore, we call upon the cor­re­spon­dents of the Sat. TVs to aban­don mis­lead­ing styles of report­ing and act real­is­ti­cally as they cover the events.
We reit­er­ate our com­mit­ment to facil­i­tate jour­nal­is­tic activ­i­ties in Kur­dis­tan.
The Con­sec­u­tive Coun­cil of
Kur­dis­tan Jour­nal­ists Union
Erbil City
4th April 2003

While the Kurds are jus­ti­fi­ably proud of the media free­doms they enjoy in their region, this state­ment shows the depth of sup­port for the war among the Kur­dish lead­er­ship. That sup­port is reflected among aver­age Kurds, as well.
Amer­i­cans — and by exten­sion, the war — are very pop­u­lar here. I’ve had to force money into mer­chants’ hands. The smiles are gen­uine, and the offers to help are too numer­ous to accept. This may be the only place other place earth — except the USA, of course — where Amer­i­cans are so well-liked.
All that aside, I can’t help but worry. Today has been a bad day for jour­nal­ists, with per­son­nel from Al Jazeera and Reuters killed today in the fight­ing in Bagh­dad. A Span­ish (I don’t know the affil­i­a­tion) cam­era­man was also killed. The Reuters cam­era­man, a Ukrain­ian, was killed, and sev­eral other jour­nal­ists injured, when an Amer­i­can tank opened fire on the Pales­tine Hotel, scor­ing a direct hit on the Reuters office. The Amer­i­cans say the tank was respond­ing to a sniper in the hotel, but reporters on the floors above and below the Reuters office say they heard no sniper fire or RPG fire in the area in the 20 min­utes before the tank fired. In sev­eral videos of the attack filmed by inde­pen­dent cor­re­spon­dents, there was no sound of small arms fire.
I don’t want to crit­i­cize the tank com­man­der, since the only thing I know about this is what I can watch on BBC right now. But some inner voice asks why the tank opened up on a tar­get that was well-known as the head­quar­ters for west­ern jour­nal­ists. I’m not say­ing jour­nal­ists were tar­geted, but was there no alter­na­tive to lob­bing a tank shell into a hotel?
Today shows the dan­ger of this whole damn thing, not only to sol­diers, but to jour­nal­ists and civil­ians, too. If a tank gun­ner is will­ing to open up on a hotel to take out a sniper, would he open up on a hos­pi­tal? An apart­ment build­ing?
*Sigh* I guess we should chalk this up to a tragic mis­take, just one of those things that hap­pen. After all, the journos were there on their own free will. Unlike the cit­i­zens of Bagh­dad, they made the choice to be in the fir­ing line. But it’s still sober­ing reminder of the per­ils of war.
In an attempt to whis­tle past the grave­yard, I taped up the win­dows, side pan­els and roof of my driver’s car today with “TV” (the uni­ver­sal sym­bol for press around here.) But blue tape won’t stop a JDAM once it’s been tar­geted. Frey­doon, my dri­ver, is a good guy, and loyal. He told me today that a friend of his, a pesh­merga named Isam, is dying. He was in the con­voy attacked two days in the friendly fire inci­dent that killed up to 20 pesh­mer­gas. With the jour­nal­ists’ deaths in Bagh­dad, and the news of Freydoon’s friend, I look south to the front lines with apprehension.

Chemical Ali’s death celebrated in Arbil

ARBIL, Iraqi Kur­dis­tan — A lot has hap­pened today. It seems the assault on Bagh­dad has begun, with a num­ber of impor­tant and sym­bolic build­ings now under con­trol of the Amer­i­cans, includ­ing a num­ber of Saddam’s pres­i­den­tial palaces. Per­haps most dra­mat­i­cally for the Kurds, though, the British say they have killed Ali Has­san al-Majid (“Chem­i­cal Ali”) in the attack on Basra. Al-Majid was the man in charge of the Hal­abja mas­sacre in 1988 that left 5,000 Kurds dead.
In the Inter­net cafe where I was typ­ing this, sev­eral young Kurds were hard-pressed to pull them­selves away from Al Jazeera, which was broad­cast­ing the Fox News cov­er­age from inside one of the cap­tured palaces. They gaped and then tut-tutted at the gold plat­ings in the bath­rooms on the screen.
“In four days, Sad­dam will be gone,” said Faisal Adil, 24, a final-year law stu­dent at the Uni­ver­sity of Sula­haddin near Arbil. As for al-Majid, “We are very happy now,” he con­tin­ued. “He was a crim­i­nal. He was a killer, a Kur­dish killer.”

Update on Blue on Blue

ARBIL, Iraqi Kur­dis­tan — A lit­tle more infor­ma­tion and clar­i­fi­ca­tion on the “blue on blue” (friendly fire) inci­dent yes­ter­day in Iraqi Kur­dis­tan.
Twenty-two Kur­dish fight­ers and five Spe­cial Forces died. Forty-five pesh­mer­gas were wounded, includ­ing Waz­eri Barzani, a brother of KDP pres­i­dent Mas­soud Barzani.
The attack hap­pened not because of the cap­ture of Iraqi tanks, as early reports from Fawzi Hariri said yes­ter­day, but because a Spe­cial Forces com­man­der in the attacked con­voy called in air strikes on a nearby Iraqi tank col­umn and the Amer­i­can pilots hit the con­voy by mis­take.
More details as they become available.

Arbil in Mourning

ARBIL, Iraqi Kur­dis­tan — We arrived today in Arbil, the seat of the Kur­dis­tan Regional Gov­ern­ment, to find a city on edge and in mourn­ing. An Amer­i­can fighter jet had just hit a con­voy of pesh­mer­gas and U.S. Spe­cial Forces in a friendly fire inci­dent that left at at least seven Kur­dish fight­ers and pos­si­bly three Amer­i­can troops dead. Also killed were sev­eral civil­ians, includ­ing the trans­la­tor for BBC’s John Simp­son, Kam­eran Abdul­raz­zaq.
The details of the attack remain unclear, but the attack by an F-15E Strike Eagle seems to have occurred after the lightly armed Kurds and Amer­i­can troops cap­tured one or two Iraqi tanks intact, said Fawzi Hariri, assis­tant to the head of the Inter­na­tional Affairs bureau for the KDP. The pilot of the Amer­i­can plane mis­took the allied forces on the ground and attacked.
Abdul­raz­zaq, an engi­neer by train­ing, was a Simpson’s trans­la­tor. When he couldn’t find a job, one of Hariri’s aides told me, he took the job with the BBC to earn money.
Simp­son him­self was slightly injured in the attack, and one of the BBC’s vehi­cles was almost destroyed. The inci­dent occurred ear­lier today on the road between Peear­dawid and Dybaga, beyond Kalek toward the Iraqi front, Hariri said.
As J. and I pulled up to the hotel, we saw the husk of the BBC Range Rover. All its win­dows were blown out and it’s front and back ends showed clear impact dam­age. The front was torn to hell and burned a bit. It’s a mir­a­cle they were able to get it back to the hotel.
The city itself seems edgy and ner­vous, as can well be expected. Many res­i­dents are glued to Al Jazeera, seek­ing news of friends or rel­a­tives who may have been injured. [J. told me later that he ran into a man on the street who asked if he was Amer­i­can and asked about the inci­dent. J. tried to explain that it was an acci­dent, he said, but the man just shook his head and said, “Very bad, very bad.” It remains to be seen how this attack will affect the Kurds’ feel­ings towards the United States, espe­cially con­sid­er­ing the brother of Mas­soud Barzani, head of the KDP was among the injured.]
Wel­come to the war.
[From Chris, 10:39 p.m.: I added some stuff from J. and edited a lit­tle bit — fix­ing line end­ings and mov­ing Hariri’s attri­bu­tion up so it made sense. Such are the haz­ards of mov­ing para­graphs around using copy and paste sometimes.]

The Long March

DUHOK, Iraqi Kur­dis­tan — Our “travel agent” in Turkey was a bit mis­in­formed. After con­tract­ing with the Kur­dish coy­otes to take us into Zakho, we were told we would cross a small river and then walk two of three kilo­me­ters to a truck that would take us to Zakho.

This was a big lie.

Our guide with the rocky teeth that we met in the alpine field was more of a baby sit­ter. He took us to a safe-house in a vil­lage on the Turkish-Iraqi bor­der. We had a din­ner of rice, cucum­bers, toma­toes and naan, the bread served with every meal here. Soon three men showed up. Only one, a small man with a wrestler’s physique and a ready smile, gave his name: Çimli. The other two were friendly, but didn’t talk much. They shook our hands and smiled, and then talked amongst them­selves for a while. No one spoke Eng­lish and J. and I don’t speak Turk­ish or Kur­manji, the Kur­dish dialect.

We waited around for about an hour, killing time by watch­ing Kurd­Sat record­ings of pop­u­lar Kur­dish singers. The smug­glers occu­pied them­selves with a great deal of com­ing and going. Finally, we were ready to go. The five of us shoul­dered the packs — the smug­glers refused to let us carry our own — and set out. As the small­est of the party, I got stuck car­ry­ing the food and the chai set. I was a walk­ing tea cozy.

Once out of the safe-house, we were loaded in the back of a trac­tor, where J. and I laid down as flat as we could, watch­ing the stars stream by over­head. After a short but vertebrae-bruising ride, we were let out on the side of the road. A cou­ple of quick words and the five of us, J., myself and our three coy­ote guides, set off down a hill.

To our left we could plainly see the Turk­ish encamp­ments about 1 km away. With a ring of lights and perched on a hill­side, they looked like downed fly­ing saucers. We hoofed it down sev­eral hills for another kilo­me­ter or so, and then came to a river — the Heyil Cayi, accord­ing to my map. The Turk­ish base was very close now, per­haps 500 meters away. Down under­neath the bridge, two sen­tries were on duty.

J. pulled out his night vision gog­gles and handed them to Çimli, who was very impressed. He smiled at J. in the dark­ness, his teeth gleam­ing in the Turks’ flood lights. “Amrika,” he said. “Bosch!” Good.

The gog­gles gave us a tremen­dous advan­tage. The Turk­ish sen­tries, stu­pidly, were also smok­ing, show­ing us exactly where they were. From the dark­ness of the river­bank, even I could see the ember of their cigarettes.

Çimli started tim­ing the sen­tries. When they turned their backs and started walk­ing down­stream away from the bridge, we made a run for it.

We scram­bled down the river­bank, and hit the bridge. Run­ning in a crouch, we were in full view of the base, whose inhab­i­tants had thought­fully lighted the whole bridge like Yan­kee Sta­dium at night. We were run­ning through the “kill zone,” a patch of ter­ri­tory where it would be more than easy to pick off targets.

Halfway across, and the juice kicked in. I no longer cared if I was seen or not and broke into a full scale sprint. J. was close behind me, but even with his longer legs he couldn’t catch me. Huff­ing and spit­ting, we made it to the other side, pro­tected by rocks. I almost took a tum­ble, but righted myself in the nick of time before dash­ing my head against a large boul­der just at the end of the bridge.

All of us across, we kept a mean pace until we were well out of sight of the Turks. Finally, we rested next to a spring. Each of us drank our fill under the sky and one of our guides turned to me and J.

Turk­ishiye, no prob­lem,” he said and wiped his hands together.

Prob­lem yok,” I replied. No prob­lem. It was in Turk­ish, but he smiled anyway.

Now the jour­ney got rough. J. and I had naively believed N. when he said that we would cross the river and take a lit­tle two or three kilo­me­ter hike, and then there would be a truck to take us to Zakho. We had already done the 2 – 3 km trek and were think­ing, “This isn’t so bad” when Çimli and Co. took us off trail. What fol­lowed from there were some of the most hell­ish hours of my life.

We had started out from the safe-house at around 9 p.m. It was now after mid­night and it was pitch black. We wouldn’t stop march­ing and climb­ing until sunrise.
We climbed three moun­tains that night, up and down. Accord­ing to the altime­ter in my GPS receiver, we were up around 5,500 feet at one point. And these moun­tains weren’t gen­tle slopes nor was there a flat sur­face on them. Each step was a gam­ble, hop­ing that I wouldn’t lose my foot­ing and tum­ble down into the river we were fol­low­ing some 300 – 400 feet below. Often the “trail” wasn’t even vis­i­ble, known only to Çimli and his cohorts from years tra­vers­ing this ter­rain. My ankles ached from the twist­ing. My calves and quads burned. My com­bat boots thank­fully had a good tread and didn’t slip under­neath me — much — but the steel caps banged my toes painfully, rip­ping the nails from three of them.

We stopped once that night, for about an hour. As the walk­ing tea cozy, it was imper­a­tive I sur­vive, so I was pushed, hauled and lugged up a sheer cliff to a roomy cave in the side of the moun­tain where we had a very civ­i­lized sec­ond din­ner. Çimli sang J. Lo songs and J. taught the smug­glers words for the var­i­ous makes of rifles. We were quickly becom­ing friends.

We tried to talk to them, find out how far it was to go. But the answer to “Kak kilo­me­ter Zakho?” How many kilo­mters to Zakho? was always the same: “Bir kilo­me­ter!” One kilo­me­ter! “One kilo­me­ter straight up?” I asked. Çimli just made an up and down motion with his hand like waves. Not encouraging.

It was get­ting cold now, and we walked and walked some more. The moun­tains in the Turkish-Iraqi bor­der region are either one big rock with sheer faces and very few hand– and toe­holds, or piles upon innu­mer­able piles of bro­ken, sharp shale that shift under your feet and cut at the your ankles. While my boots were high enough to pro­tect from the cut­ting, they didn’t allow enough ankle rota­tion to walk along the moun­tain sides like a moun­tain goat. Our guides, clad in Iraqi web belts, Kur­dish pants, mil­i­tary jacket and tot­ing Kalish­nikovs, also wore Nike and Reebok ten­nis shoes. Their ankles were as thick as PVC pipes. They, of course, had no prob­lem on these slopes.

By dawn we were close to another Turk­ish base, and I was hal­lu­ci­nat­ing. I imag­ined the guide in front of me was Emre, from Diyarbakir, and I couldn’t under­stand why he wasn’t respond­ing to me when I called out to him. Çimli and the guys needed to get to a hid­ing place because I wasn’t going to make it much longer. The pace they had set was bru­tal. On a flat, paved sur­face, it would have been a brisk walk, the kind that leaves one a bit winded after half an hour. This was over unsta­ble ter­rain, at night, up and down sev­eral times. And they never really stopped. And they did it car­ry­ing our packs, which weighed 30 – 40 pounds each. I have a great deal of respect for these guys, espe­cially since they seem to live on moun­tain air, chai and cigarettes.

As light was break­ing over us, we were almost to the shel­ter, a clus­ter of rocks that pro­tected us from Turk­ish snipers. But we had to cross an old min­ing oper­a­tion that had blasted an entire side of a moun­tain — which we had to clam­ber up, of course — into tril­lions of lit­tle pieces of shale. They just fell away in my hands, and it was like climb­ing a sand dune, except every grain of sand cuts through your skin. My hands will bear many scars after this.

Near the top, I gave out. I couldn’t make and begged Çimli to leave me, shoot me or some­thing. It was not one of my finer moments. This was the one time I was glad he didn’t speak Eng­lish. Instead, he hauled me up by my coat col­lar, pulled me up the slope and onto a road. Finally, we made it to the shel­ter where they dumped me behind some rocks and cov­ered me with a cam­ou­flaged tarp so the Turks wouldn’t see me. I slept for an hour before I awoke, shiv­er­ing. I drank some chai and fell back asleep until mid-morning. We would stay at that lit­tle camp until 1 p.m.

After that night, I wasn’t sure it could get worse. It did. All day and into the night we marched, never stop­ping for more than 10 min­utes at a time. The GPS receiver didn’t work here and I sus­pect the U.S. was jam­ming the sig­nal in the region. It still showed us in the lit­tle meadow where we thought this would be a light lit­tle adventure.

By night­fall, we were in the snows of the moun­tains, doggedly walk­ing. I no longer knew any­thing or cared about any­thing except plac­ing my feet in the foot­steps of the pesh­merga before me. When I could, I would reach down and grab a hand­ful of snow to suck on, hop­ing for some hydra­tion. It helped… a little.

I don’t know what time we entered the val­ley and finally saw Zakho in the dis­tance, but it was before mid­night. We were being handed off to two KDP pesh­mer­gas, Abdul­lah Karim and Sabdi. Abdul­lah was the younger of the two, look­ing a bit like Fred­die Mer­cury in his prime. Sabdi was obvi­ously an old war­rior, with his gray­ing red hair and fad­ing mus­tache. But he was a tough old slug­ger. They took our packs from us. I, of course, was again the walk­ing tea cozy.

For $200 they would take us to Duhok, which was fine with me. I was too exhausted to hag­gle, and in the light of the cig­a­rette lighter by which we con­ducted the trans­ac­tion, Ben Franklin seemed to be mak­ing faces at me.

That night, we walked until morn­ing, through more snow, and with only another hour to sleep. I fell down where we stopped and didn’t get up until they made me.

Mis­ter, mis­ter!” Abdul­lah hissed, pok­ing me with his rifle. I woke up fast.

At day­break we started out again, climb­ing up and down hills. Abdul­lah was enthu­si­as­tic and funny, mak­ing dri­ving noises and warn­ing us of Turk­ish tanks that shell the cabs on the road to Zakho. J. couldn’t under­stand why the Turks would do this, as we were in Iraq, a sov­er­eign coun­try, and the Turks were shelling civil­ians. At point, later in the day, we would come across an unex­ploded clus­ter mine, dropped from a plane. Also, I picked up a few pieces of Turk­ish shrap­nel, left over from where the Turks had shelled the field. The road, which we avoided until well out of sight of the Turk­ish base, was pock­marked and scarred from the bar­rages. How did shelling Kur­dish civil­ians and taxis enhance Turk­ish secu­rity? I wondered.

At one rest break, Abdul­lah filled us in on his view of world pol­i­tics. “George Bush: Okaaaaaay!” he said, and gave a big thumbs up. Tony Blair got the same treat­ment. “Don­ald Rums­feld, Colin Pow­ell, Con­deleeza RIce,” he said, tick­ing off their names on his fin­gers. “Bosch!” But he lit­er­ally held his nose and sneered when he came to the names of French Pres­i­dent Jacques Chirac and Ger­man Chan­cel­lor Ger­hard Schroeder. He even found it in his heart to dis France’s ambas­sador to the United Nations.

He asked if J. and I had chil­dren. We didn’t but he did. He had five, he said. But then he started tick­ing them off again. The first one was killed by the Turks. The sec­ond by the Ira­ni­ans. The third by the Syr­i­ans and the fourth by the Iraqis. For all the death Abdul­lah has seen per­son­ally, he seemed remark­ably unbit­ter. But he was a full-on, “let’s roll” sup­porter of this war.

Sad­dam, krrreeeeeek!” he said, and made a slic­ing motion across his throat. “Amrika, Kurdi dost!” he said, indi­cat­ing the friend­ship that existed between the Kurds and the United States. I felt such com­pas­sion for him at the moment, I wanted to hug him. Instead, I pat­ted his arm and nod­ded. “Friends,” I said. I des­per­ately hoped I wasn’t lying to him.

After another four hours of march­ing, we finally made it to the taxi, which was a pickup truck dri­ven by Abdul­lah. We had to go through a lit­tle mil­i­tary intel­li­gence rou­tine by a Kurd call­ing him­self “Che Gue­vara.” (That’s him on the left in the attached pic­ture. J is in the mid­dle.) If any oper­a­tional details of this trip leaked out, they would know who to pinch. I think I’m OK, since I don’t know any details.

Finally, Duhok. It was gru­el­ing jour­ney and I can hear the bombs falling on Mosul less than 40 miles to the south. One was large enough to shake the win­dows of the hotel while I was writ­ing this. I won­der if the trip over the moun­tains was really worth it… Tomor­row, Arbil.