Where Things Stand Tonight

BAGHDAD — It’s Sat­ur­day night in Bagh­dad, and it’s been a busy day. The funeral of a well-known jour­nal­ist was attacked west of Bagh­dad and one per­son was killed and four peo­ple injured. On the way back to town, the funeral pro­ces­sion hit an IED, which destroyed a car or two. An unknown num­ber of peo­ple were injured, but no one (else) was killed, thank good­ness.
In Kar­bala, a car bomb exploded at a police check­point on the out­skirts of the Shi’ite holy city, killing sev­eral police­men and an unknown num­ber of civil­ians. Weirdly, a man was appre­hended nearby who allegedly det­o­nated the bomb via remote con­trol. Reports are that he said the real tar­get was the shrine to Imam Hus­sayn in Kar­bala, which holier than the Askariya shrine destroyed in Samarra.
One of my staff mem­bers reports that there is fight­ing on his street tonight, and sev­eral neigh­bors have already been killed. He lives in a pri­mar­ily Sunni neigh­bor­hood in west Bagh­dad.
The cur­few was extended today to 6 p.m., but it is to be lifted tomor­row at 6 a.m. We’ll see what hap­pens. Right now, there’s a feel­ing that the ten­sion has eased some­what, but that may be false secu­rity. Shi’ite mili­ti­a­men, prob­a­bly Mahdi Army, and Sunni gun­men fought pitched bat­tles in the streets of south­ern Bagh­dad yes­ter­day and today, while the Iraqi police and Army — praised by the Amer­i­cans and the Iraqi “gov­ern­ment” for their pro­fes­sion­al­ism and effi­cacy — stood by and watched. Dur­ing the Lebanese Civil War (19751990), the Lebanese Army sat out much of the con­flict there, allow­ing mili­tias free reign. The same is hap­pen­ing here in Bagh­dad today.
It’s clear the author­i­ties, at least the ones who appear on tele­vi­sion with titles such as “Defense Min­is­ter” and “U.S. Ambas­sador,” have no clue what to do. Their strat­egy seems mainly to con­sist of bet­ting that Moq­tada al-Sadr and the hard­line Sunni group, the Mus­lim Cler­ics Asso­ci­a­tion, “really will make nice”:http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/common/story_page/0,5744,18278442%255E1702,00.html. Four sheikhs asso­ci­ated with al-Sadr and MCA spokesman Abdel Salam al-Qubasi pub­licly pledged a “pact of honor” and promised to end attacks. That’s nice. While these men were on tele­vi­sion play­ing polit­i­cal foot­sie, we had reports that their fol­low­ers were still try­ing to kill each other. There’s a real his­tory here of say­ing one thing and doing another. We’ll have to see.
More balder­dash from the Amer­i­cans, of course. U.S. Ambas­sador Zal­may Khalilzad gave another press con­fer­ence tonight in which he said the Iraqi “gov­ern­ment” was hold­ing lots of meet­ings, and that was good. Also, the Iraqi “gov­ern­ment” has decided to ban peo­ple “who should not have arms” from patrolling the streets. “I think the gov­ern­ment deci­sion to ban that was a good thing,” he said.
Well, sure. But in my expe­ri­ence, men with guns in their fists and rage in their hearts don’t wait around for their weapons license to come through when there’s killing to be done. And who is going to enforce this ban? The police? Badr Brigade mem­bers con­trol the police of most of the south­ern cities. An entire Pub­lic Order Bat­tal­ion in Bagh­dad is com­posed of Mahdi Army. In Anbar, most of the Army units are Shi’ites and Kurds. What hap­pens when Mahdi mili­ti­a­men run into a squad of their broth­ers in the police? Do you think they’ll turn in their guns? Or what hap­pens in Anbar, where many of the police forces in the cities are now local (Sunni Arab) guys? Do you think they’ll con­fis­cate the AK-47s of their _mujahideen_ broth­ers off to fight the Shi’ite mem­bers of the 1st Divi­sion down the road?
I don’t.
We have reached a point where the facade of the “polit­i­cal process” has been shred­ded. The real power lies — and has always lain — in the hands of the sheikhs, the cler­ics — espe­cially Moq­tada — and the gun­men. The politi­cians in Bagh­dad can con­tinue their silly lit­tle exer­cise in gov­ern­ment build­ing and the Amer­i­cans and the for­eign diplo­matic corps can tell their audi­ences in their home coun­tries how much progress Abdul Aziz al-Hakim is mak­ing at build­ing bridges with Saleh Mut­lak. But we on the ground know the truth. We’re on the edge of a hot knife, and it’s get­ting hot­ter. There may be a pause now, but only for now. And we might have pulled back from the abyss just in time. This might end soon after all and my doom-saying will be proven wrong.
But I don’t think so. If there’s another bomb­ing of a Shi’ite shrine, or some other mas­sacre of Sun­nis, then all bets are off. Sis­tani has already instructed his fol­low­ers to take mat­ters into their own hands if the gov­ern­ment can’t keep them safe. For Iraqis, their fate appears to lie with the scruffy young men stand­ing at the ends of their streets, not with the politi­cians in the Green Zone.

Head in the Desert Sand

Unbe­liev­able:

In Wash­ing­ton, the State Depart­ment insisted that US pol­icy in Iraq was suc­ceed­ing and denied that polit­i­cal nego­ti­a­tions had col­lapsed, only that they had paused. “Come on, let’s not blow this out of pro­por­tion,” said spokesman Adam Ereli. He denied reports of wide­spread vio­lence, speak­ing of “some incidents”.

Look, I’m really sorry real­ity is intrud­ing on your lit­tle fan­tasy but a lot of peo­ple are prob­a­bly going to die in the com­ing days and weeks because of the idea that if you just repeat some­thing enough times, it will come true.
Enough already. Shut your mouths; you peo­ple in Wash­ing­ton have caused enough dam­age already.

Journalist’s Funeral Attacked

BAGHDAD — In an omi­nous sign rem­i­nis­cent of the atroc­i­ties com­mit­ted in the Balkan Wars, the funeral of “Atwar Bah­jat, an al-Arabiya jour­nal­ist killed Wednesday”:http://abcnews.go.com/International/wireStory?id=1655859, is under attack right now in a west­ern sub­urb of Bagh­dad.
As I watched the cov­er­age this morn­ing, a cor­re­spon­dent trav­el­ing with the funeral party called into al-Arabiya, say­ing the funeral pro­ces­sion was under attack by gun­men in the neigh­bor­hood of al-Haswah, a Sunni area. The sound of gun­shots could clearly be heard around the cor­re­spon­dent and there was a note of panic in his voice. Four peo­ple have been injured and one killed, so far.
The funeral pro­ces­sion was a mixed Sunni and Shi’a affair, because Bahiat, a styl­ish 26-year-old female cor­re­spon­dent for al-Arabiya who was killed Wednes­day in Samarra as she was cov­er­ing the bomb­ing there, came from a mixed fam­ily. The funeral pro­ces­sion had police cars on either end of it, and this may have caused the inhab­i­tants of al-Haswah to believe the pro­ces­sion was led by Shi’as com­ing to attack them with gov­ern­ment sup­port.
Ten­sions here are so high that any no one should think of mov­ing between neigh­bor­hoods, or within a mixed neigh­bor­hood. The Amer­i­cans have been almost invis­i­ble, except for an air pres­ence. Apaches and Black­hawks buzz the city, snarling by over­head as their pilots watch the city’s mil­i­tants entrench them­selves for a bat­tle that, from the ground, seems inevitable.

Sunnis hitting back

BAGHDAD — There are scat­tered reports that the Sunni gun­men and oth­ers have begun strik­ing back against Shi’a neigh­bor­hoods and reli­gious sites. We’re hear­ing that attacks on Shi’a posi­tions are hap­pen­ing right now in Kad­himiya, Doura (a mixed neigh­bor­hood) and Adhimiya, a Sunni area, but with some Shi’as liv­ing there.

There is a report that in Shu’aybah in Basra, the tomb of “Anas ibn Malik”:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anas_ibn_Malik, one of the Prophet’s Com­pan­ions, has been blown up. I have no fur­ther details on this.

The cur­few that locked down the cen­ter of the coun­try today has been extended into tomor­row. No move­ment from 8 p.m. tonight, three hours ago, until 4 p.m. tomor­row afternoon.

At least 158 peo­ple have been killed in Bagh­dad in the last two days, accord­ing to police, Inte­rior Min­istry and Bagh­dad morgue sources. It is unknown how many have been killed around the coun­try. The Mus­lim Cler­ics Asso­ci­a­tion, a hard­line Sunni orga­ni­za­tion, says that more than 168 of their mosques have been attacked around the coun­try. While this num­ber may be inflated, we have inde­pen­dent sources that say at least 100 have been attacked. So let’s put the num­bers between those two … for the present.

The peo­ple who planted the explo­sives in the Askariya shrine in Samarra on Wednes­day knew what they were doing. Not only in a tech­ni­cal, but also a polit­i­cal sense.

First, the tech­ni­cal side: The blasts seem to have been set by demo­li­tion experts who had plenty of time to set the charges. Now, maybe they got lucky, but I doubt it. I have a feel­ing that tak­ing down the dome was the plan all along.

On the polit­i­cal front, if you wanted to dyna­mite any kind of nascent trust that was devel­op­ing Sunni and Shi’a par­ties as they strug­gled to form a gov­ern­ment, this was the way to do it. The men who blasted the shrine wore Spe­cial Police Com­mando uni­forms (not dif­fi­cult to get, really) and tied up the guards mind­ing the shrine. This last detail is unusual because _jihadis_ usu­ally kill the gov­ern­ment employ­ees who fall into their hands.

And there’s been no claim of respon­si­bil­ity from any Sunni insur­gent groups. The only response has come from the the Mujahideen Shura Coun­cil, which is com­posed of seven insur­gency groups in Iraq: Al Qaeda in Iraq, Vic­to­ri­ous Army Group, the Army of al-Sunnah wal Jama’a, Ansar al-Tawhid Brigades, Islamic Jihad Brigades, the Strangers Brigades, and the Hor­rors Brigades. The state­ment read, in part:

The Mujahideen Coun­cil declares that it will not allow this overt aggres­sion and vio­la­tion on the Sun­nis and their mosques. The answer will be jolt­ing. … The Mujahideen declare that what hap­pened was con­cocted by the apos­tate gov­ern­ment of Jaa­fari and … Iran to cover up for the crimes they com­mit against (Sunni) Mus­lims. … The inci­dent in Samarra, which tar­geted one of the rejec­tion­ists’ (Shi­ite) idols, was fol­lowed by a series of events that show Mus­lims every­where what had been pre­pared secretly against the Sunnis.”

That there’s no evi­dence for any of this is beside the point. Sun­nis are quite pre­pared to believe the Shi’as, i.e., Iran, blew a holy shrine to cause chaos and cre­ate the pre­text for a give-no-ground nego­ti­at­ing posi­tion in the gov­ern­ment talks. The con­se­quent show of Shi’a strength by means of Moq­tada al-Sadr’s Mahdi Army and the Iranian-backed Badr Brigade also is a way of remind­ing the Amer­i­cans who’s really call­ing the shots in Iraq these days. So hands off that nuclear pro­gram next door!

For the Shi’as, it’s not nearly so con­vo­luted. Abu Musab al-Zarqawi, the head of AQI, has been try­ing to start a civil war for almost three years because a failed state allows him to oper­ate freely and he comes from the hard-core anti-Shi’a branch of Salafist Islam. Sim­ply put, the Shi’a are worse than the Amer­i­can infi­dels and they deserve to die.

In short, peo­ple are now to a point where they will believe any­thing that demo­nizes the other side. In the come days and weeks, look for the two groups to play “we’re more grieved than thou.”

Per­son­ally, I think _jihadis_ hit the Askariya shrine. I think they did every­thing they could to make it look like it was a Shi’a inside job so the Shi’as would ram­page (as they did) and give any Sun­nis who might have been con­sid­er­ing coop­er­at­ing with the new gov­ern­ment sec­ond thoughts. Fur­ther­more, this will slam shut any divi­sion between Ba’athists, Iraqi Islamists and _jihadis_ that the Amer­i­cans had been work­ing on for so long. Under the threat of a Shi’a onslaught, the Sunni insur­gency will put aside its differences.

The silence only feeds the con­spir­a­cies and para­noia, mak­ing it harder for Sun­nis and Shi’as to work together and stop this rush to oblivion.

Radio appearance

BAGHDAD — I will be appear­ing on WBUR, the NPR affil­i­ate in Boston for the show, “On Point” with Tom Ash­brook at 10 a.m. EST today if any­one wants to lis­ten in. The topic will be Iraq, civil war, etc. It will be syn­di­cated in New York and in many other mar­kets.
In an hour, the day­time cur­few will be over, and already I can hear the chants from Shi’ite mosque down the streets. The faint rat-a-tat of auto­matic weapon fire is clearly audi­ble. This could be a bad night. Let’s hope not.
UPDATE 4:24 p.m. +0300 GMT: There’s a report, uncon­firmed, that a crowd of 100 – 700 Iraqis have gath­ered and are march­ing toward the Min­istry of Inte­rior. Approx­i­mately 50 of the crowd are armed, but so far the march has been peace­ful.
UPDATE 6:10 p.m. +0300 GMT: Well, damn. Can­celled radio spot.