From Ankara to Diyarbakir

More dis­patches from the sum­mer. After Aykut Uzan, my fixer, and I left Ankara, we spent a few days in Cap­pado­cia. We arrived in Uçisar, after three hours of dri­ving. Aykut turned off the main high­way and onto an older, less well-maintained road. He often swerved wildly to avoid the seem­ingly end­less num­ber of pot­holes and ditches on what?s left of the ancient Silk Road, which ran from Bei­jing to Istan­bul.
Sud­denly, on our right was the Agzikara­han Car­a­vai, a 13th cen­tury hotel and way sta­tion for the car­a­vans that car­ried the spices and fab­rics between Istan­bul and Bei­jing. These car­a­vais were built by the Seljuk Turks every 30 to 40 km and fol­lowed a strict archi­tec­tural style. A cen­tral court­yard con­tain­ing a kitchen and a mosque were sur­rounded by naves and cham­bers within the thick walls. A dis­tinc­tive pointed dome was the sig­nal to weary trav­el­ers that sanc­tu­ary was nearby — but only for one night.
In Uçisar, Many were wor­ried about a loom­ing war, since Cap­pado­cia is one of the top tourist des­ti­na­tions of Turkey. Since Sept. 11, 2001, the region had been suf­fer­ing as no one was com­ing to visit. In the mid­dle of sum­mer, we were able to find a room in one of the beau­ti­ful rock hotels in town, with the rooms carved directly into the stone of the canyon walls. But after three days of Cap­pado­cia, it was time to move on. And we headed off to Diyarbakir, the flash­point for much of the war with the Kur­dish Work­ers’ Party (PKK) since 1984.
More than 37,000 peo­ple died in the civil war that raged across much of south­east Turkey from 1984 to 1998, end­ing only when Abdul­lah Ocalan, the party’s leader, was cap­tured and brought to Turk­ish jus­tice. While in cus­tody, he renounced vio­lence and sought to be a voice of rec­on­cil­i­a­tion between Turks and Kurds. Need­less to say, many Turks didn’t believe his jail­house con­ver­sion and many of his old com­pa­tri­ots in the PKK con­sid­ered him a quis­ling. He avoided the noose because of Turkey’s attempts to join the Euro­pean Union. His death sen­tence was com­muted in Octo­ber.
But Diyarbakir, with its his­toric basalt walls limn­ing the city like kohl around a Kur­dish girl’s eyes, hadn’t changed in the four years since Ocalan’s cap­ture. The streets were oppres­sive, with the pres­ence of police every­where. Aykut and I were fol­lowed the whole time we were there, and men came sniff­ing about my hotel, ask­ing the staff about me and what I was doing there. The peo­ple who did talk to me veered from the timid and wor­ried to the brave and/or fatal­is­tic. The dom­i­nant thought among the res­i­dents, who daily live under the heel of police that rou­tinely use armored per­son­nel car­ri­ers to keep order, was that even if emer­gency rule were lifted — which it was in Octo­ber — noth­ing would change as the econ­omy was so dev­as­tated, there was no hope for the peo­ple to make a liv­ing. A. Turan Demir, the deputy chair­man of HADEP, the Kur­dish party in Turkey with its strongest base in Diyarbakir, listed many of the prob­lems of the region in this inter­view I had with him: destroyed vil­lages, dis­crim­i­na­tion, intim­i­da­tion… A list of offenses that nei­ther side can ever fully for­give.
What fol­lows is a col­lec­tion of notes and emails that I took when I was in Diyarbakir (and which I emailed out after I real­ized the level of sur­veil­lance I was under.) Read­ing back over the emails and notes, I see that some of it is insen­si­tive, but I think now that the tone masks a level of frus­tra­tion both with the envi­ron­ment as a New Yorker and with the treat­ment that many peo­ple live under.

From: Christopher Allbritton
Date: Wed Jul 10, 2002 12:37:10 PM America/New_York
Subject: Update...

Hey all?
Popped into the local press office today, just to say hi, and they were expect­ing me. Creepy. There was a doc­u­ment from Ankara to say that I was com­ing and to accredit me for Emer­gency Rule Zone report­ing. Now I have TWO press cards from the Turks. I was told I could go ?any­where? and talk to ?any­one? but I sus­pect that any vis­its to HADEP offices will be frowned upon. It?s not a big deal to me, as an Amer­i­can, they would likely send me back to Ankara or Istan­bul after con­fis­cat­ing film, but my guide, Aykut, lives in this coun­try. He?s mar­ried to a Kur­dish woman and has a past involve­ment with rad­i­cal left­ist move­ments. He?s left it all behind, but I don?t want my trou­bles to spill over and cause him or his fam­ily grief.
Also, the money sit­u­a­tion is not good. My ten­ant, Theresa, has not made deposits as she said she would. If she doesn?t make some deposits by the end of this week, I?ll have to skip Iraq, head back to Ger­many and then imme­di­ately head back to the states, which would just about kill the pur­pose of all of this. I?m not pleased, obvi­ously, by this devel­op­ment. Nor will Fabi­ana be pleased either, I think, but at the moment that?s the least of my wor­ries.
Other than that, all is well. Cap­pado­cia was amaz­ing, with all sorts of oth­er­worldly, “Planet of the Apes”-style rockscapes and houses. Diyarbakir, on the other hand, is hot and oppres­sive.
I?m glad every­one is doing well, and I can?t wait to see you all again.

And this one I sent out later:
From: Christopher Allbritton
Date: Wed Jul 10, 2002 10:18:04 PM America/New_York
Subject: Lame!

Lame­lame­lame­lame­lame!
And thus, I pass judg­ment on poor, war-torn Diyarbakir. Christ, what a bor­ing town. I thought war-zones were sup­posed to bring out the deca­dence in peo­ple (Berlin, maybe?) but instead, I get sul­len­ness. Shit, the one bar that looked good, we couldn’t get in. We had not women with us.
Let me repeat that. I got turned away at the door at a bar in Diyarbakir.
Hon­estly, how lame is that? Finally, we ended up on the roof of out hotel, lis­ten­ing to the Kur­dish ver­sion of “Mr. Vegas” on a Casio key­board sing Arabesque songs in the roof restau­rant. If it weren’t for the singer, it would have been almost pleas­ant. Instead, I felt sorry for the peo­ple liv­ing the apart­ments right next door to the hotel. Some were out on their bal­cony “enjoy­ing” the singer.
Hm. Read­ing back that last para­graph leads me to believe I would be per­fect as a colo­nial gov­er­nor in, oh, 1895 or so. All that’s lack­ing is a British accent, old chap. And I’m sup­posed to be cul­tur­ally sen­si­tive. Per­haps I’m just damn tired of noth­ing work­ing right in this coun­try. Today, I had to mail a con­tract back to the states so we went to the post office. Look­ing around, there were no envelopes.
“I need to buy an enve­lope,” I told Aykut.
“You didn’t tell me that,” he said. “You have to buy those some­where else.“
What kind of post office sells stamps but not envelopes?
I feel sorry for the police peo­ple fol­low­ing us. They must be very, very bored. We walk and we eat and occa­sion­ally talk to some poor schmuck on the street. We’re not very inter­est­ing sub­jects to tail, I don’t think. Hell, tonight I was hop­ing our tails would take pity on us and pull up and say, “You look like a cou­ple of guys look­ing for some fun. Let’s have a friendly drink at the belly danc­ing palace.” Alas, such things rarely hap­pened in the Cold War, and I doubt they’re going to hap­pen now.
So that’s the score. I’m back in my hotel room (and every­thing undis­turbed, includ­ing my own hair I left stick­ing out of my lap­top in case some­one came in and opened it. Para­noia can be fun!)
So that’s all. Safe and sound. I may have an appoint­ment with the mil­i­tary gov­er­nor tomor­row. Or not. With­out doubt I will have to drink more tea. Every time I sit down in an office, a porter brings me tea in the lit­tle glasses. It’s tasty, but it’s 120 degrees Fahren­heit out­side. And the tea is hot. Aykut drinks the stuff like it was water, says it keeps him healthy and quenches his thirst, but I need real water, not hot tea.

[Ed. — I sup­pose this last sen­tence could be mis­taken for some kind of metaphor about the dif­fer­ences between the rit­u­als of the east with the cool drink of West­ern ratio­nal­ism, but I won’t bother since I never intended the lament for water to be any­thing more than a sign that I was thirsty.]
To be continued…

HADEP Deputy Chairman: “This is democracy in Turkey”

While in Ankara, Aykut and I spent a day try­ing to find the local offices of var­i­ous Iraqi and Kur­dish oppo­si­tion groups includ­ing the KDP and PUK. We were look­ing for var­i­ous offi­cials who might be able to help me when I went to Diyarbakir in the south­east and on to Iraq, but we weren’t hav­ing much luck, and kept dri­ving through twisty neigh­bor­hoods hop­ing the cops weren’t fol­low­ing us.

At one point, the com­edy descended into farce, as we drove into a mil­i­tary res­i­dence area look­ing for the embassies. We found the embassies, but the PUK still eluded us. We drove past the Jor­dan­ian, Syr­ian and Saudi Embassies, but finally stopped out­side the the United Arab Emi­rates while Aykut jumped out of the car and asked a bored-looking secu­rity guard for directions.

Excuse me, where are the offices for the Patri­otic Union of Kur­dis­tan?” Akyut asked while I shrunk into my seat and tried to look invisible.

The guard, a Turk and appar­ently no friend of Iraqi Kurds, looked him up and down, looked me up and down, and then motioned off down the road.

Aykut dropped his bulk into the dri­vers’ seat and smiled at me.

Don’t do that again,” I said.

He apol­o­gized, but at least the guard’s direc­tions were good. We finally found the rather sad look­ing house that was the office for the PUK. No one was around except for a plain­clothes guy who watched us closely and smoked a cig­a­rette like a fugi­tive. He made me ner­vous, so we left to go meet A. Turan Demir, the deputy chair­man of HADEP, the Kur­dish party in Turkey. The tran­script — from Aykut’s translation — follows:

Con­tinue read­ing

Eastward bound…

This is the sec­ond of my posts from Turkey, made after I arrived in Ankara. Prior to my arrival, I met with Turan Cey­lan, the man­ager of the Inter-Continental Hotel in Istan­bul. He’s a Kur­dish suc­cess story, one of many in Istan­bul where many Kurds have set­tled after the PKK trou­bles in the south­east dur­ing the 1980s and 1990s. I didn’t get much to get out of the inter­view, except that he is pro-EU (he’s a busi­ness­man) and he believes that dis­crim­i­na­tion against Kurds is blown way out of pro­por­tion by West­ern press (which is easy for him to say; he comes from a rich fam­ily that runs one of the largest con­struc­tion firms in Turkey.)

This was an atti­tude I dis­cov­ered among many middle-class Istan­bul res­i­dents. Aydin Kudu, my orig­i­nal fixer before he suf­fered a hip injury, had me over for din­ner and dur­ing the post-prandial tea, he and Raia, his girl­friend and some­times partner-guide, said the same thing: There is no dis­crim­i­na­tion in Turkey; Kurds can do what­ever they like, as long as they don’t break any laws.

On one level, they have a point. At least one pres­i­dent of Turkey, Turgut Ozal, has claimed Kur­dish ances­try and Istan­bul has seen a num­ber of Kurds other than Cey­lan rise to suc­cess in the busi­ness­world. But there is a great deal of unknown truth in the state­ment that “Kurds can do what­ever they like, as long as they don’t break any laws.” But until recently, it was ille­gal to be Kur­dish. It was ille­gal to teach or sing in Kur­dish. Yes, Kurds could suc­ceed in Turkey, but only if they assim­i­lated and acted Turk­ish. And even then, if someone’s ID card listed them as hail­ing from the south­east, they would often be greeted with sus­pi­cion and had a harder time find­ing jobs in the more cos­mopoli­tan west­ern part of the country.

At any rate, this gave me much to think about. So after a cou­ple of days, I took a bus from Tak­sim in Istan­bul where Aykut Uzun, my fixer, met me. After five hours on the road in Turkey, I was glad to see him.

Con­tinue read­ing

Holy crap, I’m in Istanbul (redux)

This was my email to a list of friends and fam­ily that I sent out after I landed in Istan­bul and started my trip. Except for some minor edit­ing (typos, spelling errors, con­ti­nu­ity and some gram­mar clean-up) this is what went out, more or less (except for really stu­pid, per­sonal stuff.) This entry was emailed July 2, 2002 while I was over­look­ing the Bosporus, the nar­row strait that divides the city and the two con­ti­nents of Europe and Asia.
This is the first entry of a con­tin­u­ing series of my emails and jour­nal entries of my trip over there. It’s designed to whet your appetite so you will send me back. (Hint: Donate but­ton is over to the right.)

From: Christopher Allbritton
Date: Tue Jul 2, 2002 3:20:59 AM US/Pacific

Istan­bul!
I landed at Atatürk Inter­na­tional yes­ter­day at 3 p.m. or so after a cou­ple of hours cool­ing my heels in Budapest. Took a bus to Tak­sim, the cen­tral plaza in the “mod­ern” part of the city, and from there, I took a taxi up to Boğazi’i Uni­ver­sity, where I’m stay­ing thanks to the hos­pi­tal­ity of Prof. Deniz Ilgaz.
Damn, this is a con­fus­ing place. The street energy is like New York at a rave but with­out the feel­good vibe. The taxi dri­vers are homi­ci­dal (and sui­ci­dal) and the cars bear the scars of numer­ous encoun­ters with bumpers and doors and hap­less pedes­tri­ans. The city passes by in a blur, but ancient struc­tures exist among mod­ern sky­scrap­ers and west­ern fast­food chains. It’s all a bit over­whelm­ing.
And Turk­ish is just impos­si­ble. But first, some basic geog­ra­phy: Istan­bul is divided in half by the Bosporus, duh, into Euro­pean and Asian (Ana­to­lian) sides. The Euro­pean side is fur­ther divided into North and South parts by the Golden Horn, a great nat­ural har­bor. South is the old, Ottoman city with all the tourist stuff (Aya Sofia, the Blue Mosque, yadda yadda yadda.) In the 19th cen­tury this part of the city, called Eminönü, was left to the Sul­tans as an Ottoman play­ground with harems, palaces, hookahs, and the whole Dis­ney­land on opium thing. The north­ern part, (Bey­oğlu) where I’m stay­ing, was mod­ern­ized, with street­cars, tele­phones, plumb­ing, etc. So I have to go into Eminönü to get my press creds. The office is housed in one of innu­mer­able palaces on the Bosporus. And there are a lot of them.
[Editor’s note: Here lie three para­graphs that detail the dynam­ics of a par­tic­u­larly bad liai­son I had while in Ger­many. It really doesn’t do any­one any good to rehash this stuff, so I cut them.]
Back to Turkey. I took out 200,000,000 Turk­ish Lira from my account at the air­port yes­ter­day. I’ve never with­drawn 200 mil­lion of any­thing before, so I felt like a real rich guy. (It’s about $125 or so.) I still have, after pay­ing for a cou­ple of meals, a taxi ride and a bus ride, … Uh, shit. A whole lot of zeros. Actu­ally, I still have 178 mil­lion TL, or about $111.25… Jesus, all of that cost just under $15? I could live like a king in Istan­bul if I had dol­lars com­ing in.
I’m stay­ing in an antique Ottoman house near the Bosporus ( Boğazi’i in Turk­ish, don’t ask me how to pro­nounce it.) From my win­dow, I can see the old fortress Hisar, the fort built by Sul­tan Fatih to con­quer Con­stan­tino­ple in 1453. There’s an even older fort on the oppo­site side, the Asian side, built by the Byzan­tines, and I don’t mean the East­ern Roman Empire. I mean the peo­ple who built the city of Byzan­tium that pre­dates even Emperor Con­stan­tine, who founded Con­stan­tino­ple in AD 338, if I recall the date cor­rectly.
At any rate, it’s really, really old.
And why did they change the name from Con­stan­tino­ple? That’s nobody’s busi­ness but the Turks. (Actu­ally, it’s a cor­rup­tion of a Greek term that means “in the city.”)
Today, at 2:30, I meet with Kemal Kiriş’i, a Boğazi’i Uni­ver­sity pro­fes­sor who wrote a book on the Kurds and now deals with EU-Turkey issues. I think he will be very infor­ma­tive. After that, I have to go in to the old city, across the Golden Horn, and pick up my press cre­den­tials. That should take the bet­ter part of the rest of the day. Then I’m meet­ing some peo­ple I’ve been email­ing for din­ner and that’s that. Whew!
On Thurs­day, in cel­e­bra­tion of July 4, I will get on a bus to Ankara, where I will meet my fixer. We’ll work on some logis­tics and plan for a few days and then head out to Diyarbakir and the rest of the coun­try. It’s a shame I won’t have more time in Istan­bul, as it’s a fas­ci­nat­ing city. Big­ger than NYC, too. Nine mil­lion peo­ple (although that’s only about 5.625 peo­ple thanks to the exchange rate.)
So that’s it. All is well, and I have my own Inter­net access. Life is good.