AP’s Anthony Mitchell on plane that crashed

me_and_anthony_out.jpg
Me and Anthony in a Dji­bouti bar in March — much bet­ter times.
It just not bloody fair.
Ear­lier tonight, I found out that Anthony Mitchell, a reporter for the AP based in Nairobi and one of the most inter­est­ing and funny guys I’ve met in a long time, was on a plane that crashed in Cameroon on Sat­ur­day. In all, the Kenyan Air­ways flight was car­ry­ing 114 peo­ple.
It doesn’t look good, and my heart is heavy tonight. As the report says:

Among the pas­sen­gers of the Boe­ing 737 – 800 was a Nairobi-based Asso­ci­ated Press cor­re­spon­dent, Anthony Mitchell, one of five Britons on a pas­sen­ger list released by the air­line. Mitchell had been on assign­ment in the region.

Most of the pas­sen­gers were appar­ently en route to Nairobi to trans­fer to other flights.
I met Anthony, who is 39, in March in Dji­bouti, when we both were onboard the _FGS Bremen_, a Ger­man frigate, for a story on mar­itime secu­rity oper­a­tions in the area. Anthony was full of funny, self-deprecating sto­ries about him­self and Africa, sto­ries that con­tained no small amount of hard-won wis­dom, too. He talked about the clans of Soma­lia, the US military’s actions in the Horn of Africa and con­stantly took the piss out of our mil­i­tary escort in the most good-natured way pos­si­ble. (Anthony’s from Lon­don while LCDR “Grassy” Mead­ows of the Royal Navy is from the north of Eng­land.)
I didn’t know him long, but in the few days I knew him, he was a reporter’s reporter, work­ing con­stantly, cell phone seem­ingly glued to his head as he chased down reports of the kid­napped Britons in Ethiopia and set up an inter­view with the pres­i­dent of Dji­bouti.
He was kicked out of Ethiopia last year, he said, because he upset the gov­ern­ment there. Appar­ently, they didn’t like his reports on cor­rup­tion and he was given just 24 hours to leave the coun­try. While that was no doubt a huge incon­ve­nience, I can’t help but have a soft spot for reporters who tweak the powers-that-be as much as he did.
He loved Africa, he said. He liked small towns and eschewed most of the “mod-cons,” as he called air con­di­tion­ing and the like. He also car­ried around in his wal­let a photo of his wife, Cather­ine, and his kids, Tom and Rose. They looked like a really nice fam­ily.
I wish the out­look looked bet­ter, but right now I’m left with hop­ing for the best for Anthony’s fam­ily — and for all the fam­i­lies of the peo­ple on that plane. For while this post is about Anthony — only because I know him — I know that he was just one per­son and that 114 fam­i­lies are anx­iously await­ing word.
*UPDATE 5÷7÷07 12:38:20 PM +0200 GMT:* A grim update. Cameroon offi­cials say there is “no chance” of survivors.

Death of a Scientist

Some bad news of a per­sonal nature out of Iraq today. A sci­en­tist friend of my for­mer fixer in Iraq was shot and killed in traf­fic Mon­day:

BAGHDAD — A lead­ing Iraqi aca­d­e­mic and promi­nent hard­line Sunni polit­i­cal activist was fatally shot by three gun­men Mon­day as he was leav­ing his Bagh­dad home, police said.
The killers escaped in a car after gun­ning down Essam al-Rawi, head of the Uni­ver­sity Professor’s Union and a senior mem­ber of the influ­en­tial Asso­ci­a­tion of Mus­lim Schol­ars, accord­ing to police Lt. Maitham Abdul-Razaq.
The asso­ci­a­tion is a Sunni orga­ni­za­tion believed to have links to the insur­gency rag­ing against U.S. forces and their Iraqi allies. The group has boy­cotted elec­tions and stood aside from the polit­i­cal process.
An asso­ci­a­tion offi­cial con­firmed the killing of al-Rawi, a geol­o­gist, say­ing he was behind the wheel of his car and had just left his home for the drive to work at Bagh­dad Uni­ver­sity accom­pa­nied by two body­guards.
The gun­men drove in front of al-Rawi’s car, forced it to stop, then sprayed it with auto­matic weapons fire, said the offi­cial, who spoke on con­di­tion of anonymity because he feared reprisal. One of al-Rawi’s body­guards was killed and the other was wounded, the offi­cial said.

I wrote about Dr. Al-Rawi in June 2004 for Seed Mag­a­zine, shortly after I got back to Iraq. I don’t remem­ber if the story ever ran or not as there was a pay­ment dis­pute, but here’s the story I wrote:

The sci­en­tists among the shell cas­ings
BAGHDAD — Dr. Isam al-Rawi, a geol­o­gist at Bagh­dad Uni­ver­sity, sweeps his hand over a set of dog-eared jour­nals. The arc of his ges­ture con­tin­ues on to include a bare lab­o­ra­tory with a few slices of rock sam­ples, a sag­ging chair and a drip­ping sink. The room is mean, long and nar­row, with barely enough room for a col­league to squeeze past al-Rawi car­ry­ing a tray of glasses filled to their chipped rims with Sprite. Finally his hand returns to the jour­nals and books, and he points an accus­ing fin­ger at them.
“I am a uni­ver­sity pro­fes­sor,” he says. “I need books!“
Indeed, he needs a lot more than that, but few things sum up the cur­rent state of Iraq’s sci­en­tific cri­sis more than its lack of books and jour­nals. Al-Rawi’s most recent acqui­si­tion is a pho­to­copied ver­sion of the 1998 edi­tion of the Atlas of Rock Form­ing Min­er­als, which he bought in Libya on his last trip out­side Iraq. His most recent jour­nal, a copy of the Geo­log­i­cal Soci­ety of Amer­ica Bul­letin, dates to August 1985. To a one, his books and jour­nals are old, out of date and falling apart, much like the country’s sci­en­tific com­mu­nity itself.
Before the 1991 Gulf War, Iraq’s sci­en­tists were some of the most respected in the region and they made a good liv­ing. The country’s uni­ver­si­ties churned out engi­neers, tech­ni­cians and Ph.D.s. They often did post-graduate work in the West and had access to the world’s sci­en­tific lit­er­a­ture. They trav­eled to sci­en­tific con­fer­ences all over the world.
But things started to get bad in the mid-1980s when the Iran-Iraq war was rag­ing; Sad­dam Hus­sein began restrict­ing access to sci­en­tific jour­nals. After the dis­as­trous 1991 war and the impo­si­tions of sanc­tions, things took an even graver turn. Salaries plum­meted. Al-Rawi’s monthly income went from about $2,000 a month before the 1991 war to about $400 a month. New sci­en­tists and pro­fes­sors earned about $100 a month. They could not travel; they could not sub­scribe to peri­od­i­cals, as they were for­bid­den by the sanc­tions regime. New books were too expen­sive. Much needed equip­ment, which was often marked as “dual use,” was pre­vented from enter­ing the coun­try. The Mid­dle East’s most advanced sci­en­tific com­mu­nity was effec­tively sealed up in a time cap­sule.
But now, even with most of the restric­tions gone, things are still hard 15 months after Sad­dam Hus­sein was removed from power. While sci­en­tists are no longer pre­vented from order­ing new books and jour­nals and are allowed to leave the coun­try, they often can’t for the sim­ple rea­son that they have no money to do so. And a sin­is­ter series of killings has ter­ri­fied and dec­i­mated the sci­en­tific com­mu­nity. In mid-June, Sabri Al-Bayati, pro­fes­sor of telecom­mu­ni­ca­tions at the col­lege of Sci­ence and Edu­ca­tion at Bagh­dad Uni­ver­sity was shot dead near his home in the Bab Al-Athamiya area in cen­tral Bagh­dad.‏ A few days pre­vi­ously, a physi­cian, Dr. Mohammed Abdul­lah Faleh al-Rawi (no rela­tion), was killed while sit­ting in traf­fic. Their deaths are just two of about 250 uni­ver­sity pro­fes­sors, med­ical doc­tors and engi­neers who have been killed since May 1, 2003.
“No one knows why, no one knows who,” al-Rawi says, and flicked his prayer beads back and forth.
In such an envi­ron­ment, there is no work on new research, says Dr. Nuhad Ali, a mechan­i­cal engi­neer at the uni­ver­sity. The only money being spent is to keep up the salaries of the pro­fes­sors, and the only new equip­ment are some com­put­ers paid for with the now-defunct oil-for-food pro­gram. The uni­ver­si­ties aren’t even accept­ing new grad­u­ate stu­dents, Ali says. All cur­rent grad­u­ate stu­dents, who used to receive a monthly stipend, were enrolled before the war.
But not all is hope­less, two solid state physi­cists, Dr. Izzat al-Essa and Dr. Raed al-Haddend, says they had been able to attend the Saudi Solid State Physics con­fer­ence in Riyadh in March. The praised the lift­ing of travel restric­tions, but says it was still very expen­sive.
Bagh­dad Uni­ver­sity was also lucky. Almost every other uni­ver­sity in the coun­try was looted in the civil unrest fol­low­ing the fall of Bagh­dad. But Amer­i­can troops decided to bivouac on the cam­puses of Bagh­dad Uni­ver­sity and the nearby Al-Nahrain Uni­ver­sity neé Sad­dam Hus­sein Uni­ver­sity. Their pres­ence pre­vented the whole­sale loot­ing of every­thing down to elec­tri­cal fix­tures that was going on just across town at al-Mustansiriya Uni­ver­sity.
So now the sci­en­tific com­mu­nity must rebuild with lim­ited finan­cial resources in a secu­rity vac­uum. It’s no won­der there’s an abid­ing sense of hope­less­ness among the pro­fes­sors. Al-Essa and al-Haddend dream of X-ray machines, elec­tron micro­scopes and FT-IR spec­trom­e­ters. Al-Rawi wants to replace his 1974 X-ray flu­o­res­cence machine so he can ana­lyze some rock sec­tions he recently took near Perispike in the Kur­dish area of north­ern Iraq. Dr. Emad T. Bakir, an indus­trial chemist with a spe­cialty in poly­mers, hopes for research assis­tants, cat­a­lysts and sol­vents.
But the money is sim­ply not there. The for­mer admin­is­tra­tor for the now-dissolved Coali­tion Pro­vi­sional Author­ity L. Paul Bre­mer III was found of say­ing, “Iraq is a rich coun­try that is tem­porar­ily poor.” The new gov­ern­ment is inher­it­ing many of Iraq’s old debts, includ­ing $29.8 bil­lion for war repa­ra­tions to Saudi Ara­bia and Kuwait, but the Tran­si­tional Admin­is­tra­tive Law, which is the work­ing con­sti­tu­tion for the interim gov­ern­ment, for­bids deficit spend­ing. All min­istries, includ­ing the Min­istry of Higher Edu­ca­tion, headed by Dr. Taher Kha­laf Jabur al-Bakaa, are feel­ing the vice grip of national poverty. The min­is­ter doesn’t even have a bullet-proof vest; he can’t afford one.
But if Iraqis are good at any­thing, it’s hop­ing. The sci­en­tific com­mu­nity is no excep­tion. Fuel­ing this hope is a promise promise from Bre­mer. Before he left June 28, he said he would attempt to increase com­mu­ni­ca­tions between Amer­i­can sci­en­tists at uni­ver­si­ties and their Iraqi coun­ter­parts. An Iraqi del­e­ga­tion recently returned from the Uni­ver­sity of Okla­homa whose pres­i­dent Bre­mer went to school with.
“We hope our friends in Amer­ica and Eng­land will come to see what has hap­pened to us,” says al-Rawi.

It should be noted that almost all of the mur­ders of uni­ver­sity pro­fes­sors have gone unsolved. Al-Rawi was work­ing to change that when he became a vic­tim himself.

You Only File FOIA Requests Twice

BAGHDAD — So. I filed a FOIA request on myself a while back with the CIA. Yes­ter­day my brother received a let­ter that says that after an exhaus­tive search they found “one doc­u­ment that we have deter­mined must be with­held in its entirety” based on exemp­tions to the FOIA and Pri­vacy Act laws. The exemp­tions cover dis­clo­sure of CIA “intel­li­gence sources and meth­ods, as well as the orga­ni­za­tion func­tions, names” etc of per­son­nel employed by “the Agency” and “mate­r­ial which is prop­erly clas­si­fied pur­suant to an Exec­u­tive order in the inter­est of national defense or for­eign pol­icy.“
On the one hand, I think, “Hm. What the hell does the CIA have on me, any­way?” On the other, I think, “Bitchin’! The CIA has spook stuff on me! Who’s the spy in my cir­cle of friends?” Looks like some­one in Langley’s get­ting another FOIA-gram from me…
Seri­ously, how com­mon is it for a jour­nal­ist to have a doc­u­ment about him that can’t be released for “national secu­rity rea­sons”? Any­one from the CIA read­ing this site — and server logs don’t lie, yo — want to chime in and explain? And don’t worry about me blow­ing your cover. I don’t work for the Bush admin­is­tra­tion.
UPDATE 23 March 2006 at 1231 +0200 GMT: A copy of the two page let­ter is avail­able here (page 1) and here (page 2). I won­der if this is part of Pres­i­dent Bush’s wire­tap­ping scheme or if the CIA has been “employ­ing jour­nal­ists again”:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Mockingbird, which is sup­posed to be a no-no.

The Big Lie

BAGHDAD — And no, I’m not talk­ing about WMDs or any­thing like that. More in my quixotic feud with noted fic­tion writer Ralph Peters, who came here for a lit­tle while and declared All is Well, and “the media” are aim­ing to under­mine the heroic mis­sion here in Iraq with all that bad news. Why, he him­self saw Iraqis cheer­ing his patrol as he rum­bled through Bagh­dad atop an up-armored humvee.
Let’s con­duct a lit­tle thought exper­i­ment. “The media” here are fiercely com­pet­i­tive. Every­one of us is look­ing for any angle — any! — that will break news, make our sto­ries stand out or oth­er­wise dis­tin­guish our­selves. That’s what jour­nal­ists do, and the corps here comes from the entire ide­o­log­i­cal spec­trum, from the con­ser­v­a­tive to the social­ist. But weirdly, this herd of cats — which is what we could be best be com­pared to — have all come to the same con­clu­sion: Iraq is a mess.
I would argue that this pre­vail­ing view is the aggre­gate of a lot of pro­fes­sional report­ing, mine but a small bit. If it grav­i­tates toward a sin­gle view­point, well, that’s the way it is. Sorry, truth hurts. But a guy who writes exclu­sively for pub­li­ca­tions that sup­ported the war before it went down comes here and says things are fine, and some­how I’m sup­posed to sud­denly doubt my own obser­va­tions and expe­ri­ence? Par­don me if I believe my lyin’ eyes instead of him.
But more unfor­giv­ably, Peters also “con­tin­ues his libel”:http://www.realclearpolitics.com/articles/2006/03/myths_of_iraq.html against Iraqi stringers/journalists by say­ing the “The Iraqi leg-men earn blood money for unbal­anced, often-hysterical claims.” (empha­sis added.)
Mr. Peters, you should be ashamed of your­self. Three Iraqi jour­nal­ists have been killed this week alone try­ing to report the news, and the stringer who work for us are no less the jour­nal­ists than the guys at the Iraqi net­works. Accord­ing to the Com­mit­tee to Pro­tect Journalists:

Muhsin Khud­hair, edi­tor of the news mag­a­zine Alef Ba, was killed by uniden­ti­fied gun­men near his home in Bagh­dad Mon­day night, becom­ing the third jour­nal­ist killed in Iraq in the last week, Reuters and Agence France-Presse reported. The shoot­ing took place just hours after Khu­dair attended a meet­ing of the Iraqi Jour­nal­ists Union, which dis­cussed the tar­get­ing of local jour­nal­ists in Iraq, Reuters said.
The killing punc­tu­ated a deadly week for the press. Amjad Hameed, head of pro­gram­ming for Iraq’s national tele­vi­sion chan­nel Al-Iraqiya, and dri­ver Anwar Turki were killed on Sat­ur­day by gun­men appar­ently affil­i­ated with al-Qaeda. Mun­suf Abdal­lah al-Khaldi, a pre­sen­ter for Bagh­dad TV, was killed by uniden­ti­fied gun­men last Tues­day as he was dri­ving from Bagh­dad to the north­ern city of Mosul.
At least 67 jour­nal­ists and 24 media sup­port work­ers have been killed in Iraq since March 2003, mak­ing it the dead­liest con­flict for the media in recent his­tory. The killings con­tinue two trends in Iraq: the vast major­ity of vic­tims have been Iraqi cit­i­zens; and most cases have been tar­geted assas­si­na­tions rather than cross­fire. CPJ research shows that Iraqis con­sti­tute nearly 80 per­cent of jour­nal­ists and sup­port staffers killed for their work in Iraq. Over­all, sixty per­cent of jour­nal­ist deaths were murders.

Maybe Mr. Peters would like a nice chat with “Salih” from the _Washington Post_, who reported a story about the loot­ing of Saddam’s palaces in Tikrit after the U.S. mil­i­tary turned it over to the Iraqi secu­rity forces. His reward? A $50,000 bounty put on his head by the head of secu­rity in Tikrit, Jas­sam Jabara.
Per­haps he’d like to talk to the fam­ily of Allan Enwiyah, the trans­la­tor for the _Christian Sci­ence Monitor_’s Jill Car­roll. He was killed when Jill was kid­napped Jan. 7, unpro­tected by Amer­i­can fire­power. She is still cap­tive, by the way.
Or per­haps he’d like to dis­cuss “blood money” with the widow of Yasser Sal­i­hee, a care­ful and con­sci­en­tious reporter for Knight-Ridder who was killed by Amer­i­can sol­diers at a check­point when the car in front of him blocked his view of the troops, who opened fire and killed him. Did I know him? Yes, but not well. I found out about his death when Han­nah Allam, then bureau chief for Knight-Ridder called me in hys­ter­ics.
You want to know what the Iraqis — who frankly do a bet­ter job that we do — feel and think? “Read this”:http://cjr.org/issues/2006/2/McLeary.asp. Highlight:

To get a story you have to risk your life,” [said Sal­ima] matter-of-factly. “Some­times I won­der if the peo­ple in the U.S. really under­stand how much we go through in order to write the story.” To under­score that, she told of being pushed from behind by an Iraqi man while cov­er­ing a story with a West­ern reporter, of being caught in a fire­fight in Sadr City, Baghdad’s sprawl­ing and vio­lent slum, and of being threat­ened by a group of insur­gents while out report­ing. Yet in a coun­try with few oppor­tu­ni­ties, jour­nal­ism is a way to make a liv­ing, and to stay involved. “We never know when some­thing could hap­pen to us,” she said. “But then at the same time, I can­not stop living.”

How dare you, Ralph. How dare you ques­tion these men and women’s inten­tions and hon­esty. I’ve worked with our staff in the TIME house for two years and I’ve never seen a more ded­i­cated, care­ful group of jour­nal­ists. They’re not in this for the money. We pay them well, yes, but they could make more money doing other work. Lord knows they’d be safer, and their fam­i­lies would be, too. But they come in to work every day and do their level best to get us every scrap of infor­ma­tion and to get it right. Any­one of them is a bet­ter jour­nal­ist than Ralph Peters, who feels his view from the back of humvee is the only valid one. It’s _a_ view­point, yes, but hardly the whole story. You come talk with _me_, Ralph, we’ll go walk the streets of Kar­radah, drive with­out armor, feel the cop­per in your mouth when the fear and adren­a­line comes to you in wave after wave and you real­ize the L-T from the 320th hasn’t got your six for you, man. You come talk to me then.
Finally, I’ll let a for­mer Army guy have the last word. This from a buddy of mine who was a Pub­lic Affairs Offi­cer just a few short months ago:

Oh my god, dude. [Peters] is com­pletely full of sh*t. That’s all I can say. Appar­ently that f**k hasn’t spent enough time down in the trenches here to under­stad the lit­tle bas­tards will run out and wave at any patrol for one rea­son — beg­ging for choclate or soc­cer balls. They don’t care the Grunts are valiently com­ing to save the day. … He’s not aware of how f**king dan­ger­ous it is for grin­gos to roam the streets here.

On Deadline…

BAGHDAD — Sorry for the lack of posts. I’ve been on dead­line work­ing on a project and haven’t had time. There’s much going on here in Bagh­dad, both polit­i­cally and in the streets (where the real pol­i­tics take place.) I hope to have some more analy­sis and report­ing up soon. My apolo­gies.
In the mean­time, more than 70 85 bod­ies have been found around Bagh­dad in the last 24 hours, most of them bear­ing signs of tor­ture. One of the vic­tims still had his iden­tity papers on him, which iden­ti­fied him as a 22-year-old Sunni stu­dent. How­ever, Iraqi author­i­ties are refus­ing to iden­tify the other vic­tims found around the cap­i­tal because they fear fuel­ing (more) sec­tar­ian vio­lence. Based on my expe­ri­ence here, it’s likely most of these bod­ies are of Sunni men, killed in reprisal for Sunday’s car bomb attacks in Sadr City that killed 58 and wounded more than 200. The cul­prits are prob­a­bly mem­bers of the Shi’ite-led secu­rity forces or mem­bers of the Mahdi Mili­tia, based in Sadr City.
Or, heck, there’s no rea­son the killers couldn’t be both, con­sid­er­ing how deeply the Iraqi secu­rity forces have been inte­grated into the Shi’ite mili­tias.
“No civil war here”:http://www.back-to-iraq.com/archives/2006/03/no_civil_war.php, though. Nope. Just a slaugh­ter.
Else­where, in Pales­tine, mil­i­tants rioted across Gaza after the Israelis stormed a prison hold­ing Ahmad Saa­dat, one of the lead­ers of the Pop­u­lar Front for the Lib­er­a­tion of Pales­tine. In Lebanon, today is the first anniver­sary of the mas­sive March 14 demon­stra­tions that many hoped would estab­lish a new Lebanese politics.